How to Tell if a Crystal Is Real: Simple Tests
Want this read for your own situation? Ask Chaya one question, US$10 (new clients) or Talk to a family reader on WhatsApp today, US$15.
Most fakes are glass, dyed stone or coated quartz, and you can catch them at the kitchen table. Glass holds round bubbles and warms quickly in the hand. Real quartz scratches glass. Dyed howlite shows colour pooled in its grey veins, and the rainbow sheen on aura quartz is a metal plating.
The glass fakes
Hold the stone up to a window and look for perfectly round bubbles inside. Natural quartz has flaws, but they are flat veils, wisps and angular inclusions, not bubbles. Then close it in your fist and count. Glass feels warm within a few seconds; quartz stays cold against your skin for a good while, because it carries heat away.
If you are willing to risk a small scratch, draw the point of the stone across a spare piece of glass, such as an old jar. Real quartz, with a hardness of seven, leaves a fine line. Glass on glass skids and leaves nothing. Do not try this on soft stones like calcite or selenite; they are real and will still fail it.
The dyed and the renamed
Howlite is a cheap white stone with grey veins that takes dye beautifully, and a great deal of blue turquoise on sale is howlite in disguise. Look at the veins: on dyed howlite the colour is darker in the cracks where it pooled. Real turquoise has brown or black matrix with colour that stays even. A cotton bud dipped in nail varnish remover will lift dye from a cheap piece.
Bright orange citrine is almost always amethyst that has been heated, and so is the burnt-looking colour at the base of the points. I do not mind it being sold that way, as long as the buyer knows. Untreated citrine is pale, smoky yellow and costs more.
Coatings and perfect colour
Aura quartz, angel aura and titanium quartz are clear quartz plated with a thin metal film in a vacuum chamber. The quartz is real; the rainbow is not natural. Look for a worn patch at the tip or base where the plating has rubbed off to plain crystal.
Be suspicious of any stone with an even, saturated colour and no flaws at a very low price. Nature is messy. The best rough amethyst I own has a grey crust and a chipped tip, and that is how I know it came out of the ground.
Quick tests at home
- Bubbles. Round bubbles inside mean glass.
- Warmth. Glass warms in seconds; quartz stays cold.
- Scratch. Real quartz marks glass; glass does not.
- Veins. Colour pooled in grey cracks means dyed howlite.
- Plating. A rainbow sheen is a metal coating on real quartz.
Questions people ask
Is heat treated citrine fake?
It is real quartz with its colour changed by heat. Call it what it is, pay citrine prices only for the pale untreated kind, and use it happily.
Does a real crystal feel different?
Cold and heavier than you expect. Glass and resin feel light and warm up fast. Your hand learns the difference quickly.
Can opalite be real?
Opalite is man-made glass, however it is labelled. It is pretty and harmless, but it is not opal and not a mineral.
Is a cheap crystal always fake?
No. Small tumbled quartz, agate and jasper are plentiful and cheap. It is a cheap price on a stone that should be dear, such as big turquoise or clear moldavite, that should make you pause.