Sage vs Palo Santo: Which Should You Burn?
Want this read for your own situation? Ask Chaya one question, US$10 (new clients) or Talk to a family reader on WhatsApp today, US$15.
Sage clears and palo santo softens, which is the usual answer, but I would rather you burned neither. White sage is sacred to several Native American nations and is being stripped from the wild, and palo santo comes from a protected South American tree. Garden sage, rosemary, juniper or bay will do the same work from your own cupboard.
What each one is said to do
White sage smoke is sharp and bitter, and people reach for it when a room feels heavy, after a row or after someone unwelcome has been in the house. It is a scouring smoke. Palo santo is a sweet, resinous wood and its smoke is gentler, so it is used afterwards to bring warmth back into a space that has been emptied out.
That pairing, scour then sweeten, is a sound idea and I follow it myself. The problem is not the method. The problem is where the two plants come from and who they belong to.
Why I stopped buying both
White sage grows wild in a small area of California and northern Mexico and is a ceremonial plant for several Native American nations. Demand from shops has led to it being picked illegally from public land and sold in bundles to people who have no connection to those ceremonies. Many Native voices have asked outsiders to stop, and I think the respectful thing is to listen.
Palo santo is cut from a tree that is listed as protected in parts of South America. Some suppliers claim to use only fallen wood, and some may be honest, but you cannot tell from the stick in your hand. When I cannot be sure a thing was taken fairly, I leave it on the shelf.
What my family burned instead
Nobody in my family ever owned a bundle of white sage. We burned what grew near us: garden sage from the pot, rosemary from beside the step, juniper from the hedge and bay from the tree. Garden sage gives the same clean scouring smoke as its Californian cousin. Rosemary is brighter and better for daily use. Juniper is the old protective smoke of the British Isles, and bay leaves add a warm note that does the job palo santo is sold for.
To cleanse a room, dry a few stems for a week, bind them with cotton thread, and light the tip over a heatproof dish. Let it smoulder rather than flame, walk the edges of the room, and open a window so the old air has somewhere to go.
The honest alternatives
- Garden sage. Same scouring smoke as white sage, grown in your own pot or sold for cooking.
- Rosemary. Bright, clean and kind enough to use every week.
- Juniper. The traditional protective smoke of Ireland, Wales and Scotland.
- Bay. Warm and sweet, good for closing a cleansing with a sense of welcome.
A word of care
Never leave a burning candle unattended, keep it well away from anything that can catch, and put it out before you sleep or leave the room. A snuffer or a damp cloth is fine. The old warning against blowing a candle out is tradition, not safety.
Questions people ask
Is it wrong to burn white sage if I am not Native American?
Many Native people have said it causes real harm, both to the plant and to their ceremonies. I take them at their word and use garden sage instead.
Does palo santo work better than sage?
They do different jobs. Palo santo is a sweet closing smoke rather than a cleansing one, and bay leaf gives a very similar effect.
Can I cleanse without any smoke at all?
Yes. Salt water sprinkled at the corners, a bowl of vinegar left overnight or a bell rung through each room all clear a space.
How often should I cleanse my home?
After anything that leaves the air feeling thick, and otherwise once a season is plenty for most households.
Related guides
- Rosemary in Witchcraft: Uses and Meaning
- How to Cleanse Yourself After a Bad Encounter
- How to Protect Yourself From Negative Energy
- Salt for Protection: How to Use It
- How to cleanse your home of negative energy